Nowadays parents ask their children a lot of questions. And usually for the right reasons: They want to be respectful and cooperative.
I’ve heard them asking for consent on daily decisions (“What would you like for dinner?”), disguising frustration as questions (“How many times do I have to tell you?”), or negotiating when a clear boundary would work better (“What if we take your bath first, then watch another show?”).
Questions can certainly help build relationships and encourage reflection, but they often backfire by creating confusion and unnecessary power struggles.
I have worked with over 5,000 families as a preschool teacher, professor, and child development specialist. The surprisingly simple rule I return to again and again is this: Say what needs to be said.
When questions aren’t really questions
Children do not have the experience or emotional maturity to make every decision or determine what happens next. They need clear, confident leadership.
This is why rhetorical “why” questions often elicit shyness or defensiveness. A more effective approach is to identify what you want to say and communicate it simply and directly:
- instead of: “Why do I have to ask you so many times?”
- Effort: “I’m repeating myself too many times. I know it’s frustrating for both of us. Right now, it’s time to hang up the boots and go.”
- instead of: “Why do you always do this?”
- Effort: “I see it’s becoming a pattern. It’s something we’re going to work on together.”
Do you see the difference? One approach increases shyness and defensiveness. The second invites teamwork, thinking, and problem-solving.
Say What You Want Theory
One of my fundamental parenting principles is what I call the ‘Say What You Want Principle’. Before responding, ask yourself: What am I really trying to communicate?
then say it:
- instead of: “Why did you kill your brother?”
- Effort: “You can’t hit your brother. Even when you’re angry, you can’t hit him. How can you show him in another way that you’re upset?”
- instead of: “Why is your room so messy?”
- Effort: “I see a lot of things on the floor that don’t belong there. Let’s clean it up together.”
Children need guidance more than questioning, and clarity is often more effective than questioning.
Simple tasks do not need to have questions
Another common trap is turning simple instructions into questions. Parents often say things like “Can you please put on your shoes?” or “After this show, it’s time to sleep, okay?”
The parents are trying to appear respectful and gentle, which I understand. But when non-negotiable tasks are framed as questions, children may become confused about whether the task is actually optional. After all, You asked.
This opens the door to unnecessary power struggles and a child who may perceive everything as being up for negotiation.
Instead, try making calm, direct statements:
- “Please wear shoes. We’re leaving.”
- “Dinner is ready. Please wash your hands.”
- “it’s time for bed.”
Clear leadership often helps children feel calmer and more cooperative.
Use questions to empower, not control
Questions are incredibly valuable when they help children reflect, problem-solve, express themselves, and build confidence and self-awareness. These are the conversations we want more of.
Children don’t need endless questions to feel respected. Asking fewer questions means we become more intentional about when leadership is needed, when collaboration is appropriate, and when your child needs clarity rather than dialogue.
Over time, these small communication changes can make a huge difference to your home.
siggi cohen Child development expert and author of the new book “you are a parent.” She graduated with master’s degrees in education and psychology from Pepperdine University and a PhD in philosophy from Northcentral University. She is the mother of three grown sons, and currently lives in the Bay Area, where she has a private practice.
Do you want to lead with confidence and bring out the best in your team? Take CNBC’s new online course, how to become an excellent leader. Expert coaches share practical strategies to help you build trust, communicate clearly, and inspire other people to do their best work. Sign up today!
